![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
terrikoObviously, I haven't really kept up with book reviews since my move/thesis/conference/breakin/unexpected internet fame/etc., but rest assured that I've still been reading! Anyhow, here's reviews of a couple of books I got via LibraryThing's early reviewers program:
Dragons of the Watch: A Novel by Donita K. Paul
As a fantasy, this succeeds brilliantly. Watching how Ellie (and her goat, Tak) react to the fantastical world in which they find themselves is incredibly fun. The story of adventure and compassion even in the face of those who seem at first to be enemies is surprising and adorable.
As an allegory, however, I'm less certain. There's a clever little "play within the play" moment where we are reminded that fantastical stories can serve as ways to teach lessons... but while some of the parts of the story that revolve around the God, Wulder, fit beautifully into the tale of self-discovery, I have to admit that by the end of the story I felt like some of the references were a bit bolted-on.
I still definitely recommend the book and fully enjoyed it despite this, but beware that you may feel like the religious aspect becomes a bit heavy-handed towards the end.
Skye Object 3270a by Linda Nagata
As one of the other reviewers said, this is reminiscent of great teen science fiction such as Monica Hughes' books. Think Devil on My Back or The Keeper of the Isis Light. I loved those books: a world that is both believable and alien, teenagers who are finding their place in the world, and an adventure as they stretch to learn more. I found myself caught up in the mysteries, and wanting more when it finished. I'm looking forwards to reading Linda Nagata's other books!
Dragons of the Watch: A Novel by Donita K. Paul
As a fantasy, this succeeds brilliantly. Watching how Ellie (and her goat, Tak) react to the fantastical world in which they find themselves is incredibly fun. The story of adventure and compassion even in the face of those who seem at first to be enemies is surprising and adorable.
As an allegory, however, I'm less certain. There's a clever little "play within the play" moment where we are reminded that fantastical stories can serve as ways to teach lessons... but while some of the parts of the story that revolve around the God, Wulder, fit beautifully into the tale of self-discovery, I have to admit that by the end of the story I felt like some of the references were a bit bolted-on.
I still definitely recommend the book and fully enjoyed it despite this, but beware that you may feel like the religious aspect becomes a bit heavy-handed towards the end.
Skye Object 3270a by Linda Nagata
As one of the other reviewers said, this is reminiscent of great teen science fiction such as Monica Hughes' books. Think Devil on My Back or The Keeper of the Isis Light. I loved those books: a world that is both believable and alien, teenagers who are finding their place in the world, and an adventure as they stretch to learn more. I found myself caught up in the mysteries, and wanting more when it finished. I'm looking forwards to reading Linda Nagata's other books!
no subject
Date: December 4th, 2011 05:46 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: December 9th, 2011 09:42 am (UTC)